Book Review: City of Lost Souls (The Mortal Instruments, #5) by Cassandra Clare
Well, dear readers, what a whirlwind this book was! If you had told me before diving into City of Lost Souls that I’d be left scratching my head at a three-star review, I’d have raised my eyebrows in disbelief. Yet here I am, sitting with mixed emotions about this fifth installment in Cassandra Clare’s ever-expanding universe. Let’s break down the chaos, shall we?
To begin with, City of Lost Souls shines particularly bright after its predecessor, City of Fallen Angels, which I found to be the low point of the series. Honestly, COFA dragged for me—like Breaking Dawn dragging. But oh, how refreshing it felt to read this well-crafted sequel! Compared to that past mishap, City of Lost Souls stands as a testament to Clare’s storytelling prowess, showcasing her ability to captivate readers once again.
Now, let’s talk about characters. If you know me, you know my love for Sebastian—fierce, unapologetic, and just the right amount of crazy. He radiates complexity, bringing a zesty sprinkle of chaos that makes every scene he enters pop. Seriously, I couldn’t get enough of him. He’s a snapshot of what makes these books lively: that blend of villainy and vulnerability wrapped up in formidable charisma. I mean, who wouldn’t find a character who looks like Akihiko from Persona utterly compelling? I dare say that third star of my rating is basically the “Sebastian star.”
Jace, or as I fondly refer to him, ZOMBIE, provides more layers to this intricate web of chaos. Watching him grapple with his existence as a "dead-alive" during his battle with Sebastian carved moments of introspection that drew me in—I felt a pang of empathy, despite the absurdity swirling around them. Clare’s writing effortlessly combined humor and darkness, leading me through Clary’s desperate attempts to track down Jace with a mix of exasperation and fondness for the age-old trope of “the dark hero.”
Speaking of Clary, her relentless pursuit of Jace felt both exhilarating and infuriating. Yes, girl, get that jewelry from the Faerie Queen! Spoiler alert: we all knew it wouldn’t be that easy. I often found myself chuckling at her daring (yolo, amirite?) while simultaneously lamenting that some of her choices lacked proper grounding. There’s a fine line between compelling character development and plot conveniences, and there were times when I felt that edge blur uncomfortably.
As the action raced to its heart-stopping conclusion, Clare presented moments that had me cheering, grimacing, and laughing—all in a single beat. The pacing was sharp, keeping me engaged even when plot points felt contrived. I found joy in the unexpected camaraderie embodied by side characters like Simon and the budding romance of Maia and Jordan interweaving wild subplots. They certainly added flavor to what could have been a single-minded quest narrative.
In conclusion, I’d recommend City of Lost Souls to those deep in the world of Shadowhunters, but also to newcomers who relish a story with bold characters and thrilling adventures. Clare paints a raucous picture of love, betrayal, and varied shades of morality, making this book significant in its exploration of familial bonds, personal identity, and the concept of choice. As for me, the mix of chaos and charm has left a scorching mark, reminding me of the excitement of delving into rich fantasy realms where even flawed characters can compel you to flip the pages eagerly.
So, fellow readers, grab your favorite drink, kick back, and let Sebastian and the gang take you on this wild ride through the hidden locales of their universe. Who knows? You just might find a new layer to unravel within the pages. Happy reading!
Discover more about City of Lost Souls (The Mortal Instruments, #5) on GoodReads >>
