Exploring the Depths of “Counterfeit Kingdom”
When I first stumbled upon Counterfeit Kingdom: The Dangers of New Revelation, New Prophets, and New Age Practices in the Church, I felt an immediate tug—it was an invitation to dive deeper into a world I had only somewhat brushed against. Holly Pivec and R. Douglas Geivett, both seasoned researchers on the New Apostolic Reformation (NAR), have woven a narrative that not only resonates with my own experiences in church but also raises vital questions about faith, leadership, and the nature of prophecy in contemporary Christianity.
The book opens with Pivec’s intriguing recount of her own encounters with charismatic movements, particularly through a minister’s invitation to join the NAR. As someone who has seen these dynamics unfold in various church settings, I was captivated by her candid exploration. The authors don’t merely critique the NAR; they reveal its allure and the dangers lurking beneath its surface, especially as they examine Bethel Church in Redding, California, and its far-reaching influence.
A standout theme throughout Counterfeit Kingdom is the omnipresent “Seven Mountain Mandate.” This doctrine, which claims a prophetic authority to infiltrate societal institutions, sent chills down my spine. The thought that self-proclaimed apostles and prophets believe they are tasked with governing not just the church but the world at large left me pondering ethical implications within our faith communities. As the authors succinctly put it, “Let that sink in a bit.”
Pivec and Geivett employ an engaging writing style that balances scholarly insight with accessibility. Their thorough analyses of prophecy—highlighting tests for discernment (the Orthodoxy Test, Lifestyle Test, and Fulfillment Test)—have sparked a renewed sense of vigilance in my own spiritual life. The three-fold test, in particular, resonates especially well with me, as I have often grappled with discerning the weight of prophetic messages in church circles.
One particularly memorable moment in the text came when the authors dissect how NAR groups manipulate Scripture to reinforce their views, notably through The Passion Translation. The notion that some teachings could aim to redefine core biblical narratives is both alarming and thought-provoking. It encourages readers to engage deeply with the text, reminding us that not all that is presented as “new revelation” aligns with the core tenets of the gospel.
The pacing of the book flows seamlessly—from insightful critiques to practical guidance for discerning truth amid chaos. I appreciated how Pivec and Geivett provide a roadmap for recovery from these manipulative tactics, making the reading experience both enlightening and empowering.
If you are a pastor, elder, Bible teacher, or simply someone passionate about maintaining the integrity of the gospel, Counterfeit Kingdom is essential reading. Its insights are particularly relevant in a time when church and culture are inextricably intertwined, and the stakes have never been higher.
Reflecting on my experience with this book, I feel a deeper sense of accountability—not just to my own beliefs, but also toward the broader community of faith. Pivec and Geivett have laid out a compelling case for vigilance, and I am grateful for their work. This book is more than a critique; it’s a clarion call to reclaim the essence of true discipleship and prophetic integrity in our churches.
In a world awash with competing narratives and teachings, Counterfeit Kingdom offers clarity, insight, and a path toward discernment that I wholeheartedly recommend.
Discover more about Counterfeit Kingdom: The Dangers of New Revelation, New… on GoodReads >>
