Finding Community or Just Searching for Comfort? A Review of Find Your People by Jennie Allen
When I first picked up Find Your People: Building Deep Community in a Lonely World by Jennie Allen, it felt like a glimmer of hope. The title itself was so alluring, promising guidance in a time when community feels like a distant memory for many of us. As a longtime Christian, I was drawn to the thought of exploring deeper connections, especially after experiencing my own bouts of loneliness in recent years. However, as I turned each page, I found myself wrestling with a mix of hope and disappointment that ultimately left me more frustrated than fulfilled.
At its core, Allen’s book sets out to address the universal human need for connection. She offers practical advice on building relationships, from running errands with friends to encouraging vulnerability within one’s circle. Initially, I appreciated her relatable writing style and conversational tone. Certain suggestions, like attending local events with friends or being more intentional about connections, struck a chord with me as they felt both actionable and sincere.
However, I couldn’t help but feel that beneath Allen’s warm surface lies a troubling disconnect. At times, her advice felt glaringly shallow, especially for those grappling with real-world challenges like trauma, depression, or church hurt. For instance, she dismisses the validity of painful experiences by implying that individuals are solely responsible for their social woes—if many people around you don’t like you, the problem is you. This blanket statement felt not only disingenuous but reductive, alienating those who have genuinely faced criticism or ostracization for reasons beyond their control.
Furthermore, Allen’s handling of church hurt felt particularly tone-deaf. Acknowledging that churches are filled with “sinners who sin” is one thing, but brushing off the profound scars that come from real abuse or negligence is frankly irresponsible. This disregard undermines the very core of what community should be—support, understanding, and empathy.
As I sifted through her observations about societal issues, I found her perspective disconcerting. While I appreciate critiques of Western society, her tendency to romanticize impoverished communities while glossing over their struggles seemed both naive and privileged. The implication that Western advancements disrupt fundamental human connections is a troubling narrative, especially given the stark realities many face in those communities today.
Speaking of privilege, the structure of her relationships also raised an eyebrow. While she lauded her diverse acquaintances, her close friendships appeared overwhelmingly homogeneous. This raises questions about the authenticity of her outreach—are individuals from varied backgrounds part of her circle or merely footnotes in her narrative?
Her association with a church that I found to be somewhat cultish raised further red flags for me. The emphasis on financial accountability within small groups, branded as Christian accountability, felt more like a ploy for power than genuine fellowship.
So who might enjoy Find Your People? Perhaps those seeking light-hearted affirmations and simplistic advice on community bonding. Yet for readers who are navigating deeper emotional wounds, or those looking for nuanced discussions on friendship and vulnerability, this book may not offer the depth or authenticity needed.
In the end, while I wanted to emerge from Find Your People with a renewed sense of connection, I found it lacked the realness that many of us crave. For better or worse, this book has steered me away from exploring Allen’s future works or her public discourse. This experience served as a reminder that while advice can be well-intentioned, it’s vital to approach it with a discerning heart, particularly in a world that demands truly compassionate understanding.
Discover more about Find Your People: Building Deep Community in a Lonely W… on GoodReads >>