Finding the Right Hills to Die On: A Thoughtful Journey into Theological Divisions
When I first picked up Finding the Right Hills to Die On: The Case for Theological Triage by Gavin Ortlund, I felt a mix of anticipation and curiosity. In a time when division seems more common than unity within the Christian community, Ortlund presents a relevant conversation starter: How do we discern which theological issues are truly worth dividing over? This book is a breath of fresh air, offering a nuanced perspective that is nothing short of transformative.
At its core, Ortlund navigates the delicate landscape of Christian doctrine with a four-tiered system that helps believers evaluate their theological disagreements. His framework categorizes beliefs into essential, important, and unimportant categories, guiding us in determining when separation is justified and when we should strive for unity. The book brilliantly opens with the reminder of Jesus’ high priestly prayer for unity among His followers, underscoring its significance amidst our diverse beliefs.
Ortlund’s first tier focuses on essential doctrines, the line that separates believers from non-believers—think core tenets like the Trinity and justification through faith. His emphasis on approaching these issues with humility rather than arrogance resonates deeply with me. The second tier discusses essential but non-divisive doctrines, such as baptism and views on the Lord’s Supper, which are crucial for church life but do not necessarily determine someone’s faith. I found this perspective refreshing, as it calls for all Christians to engage in these discussions without fracturing relationships.
What I appreciated most about Ortlund’s writing style is his clarity and straightforwardness. He masterfully breaks down complex theological concepts into digestible segments while maintaining a conversational tone. He doesn’t shy away from the messiness of disagreement; instead, he encourages readers to embrace the challenges that come with differing views. One of his notable quotes struck a chord with me: “Gospel doctrine and gospel culture should both be upheld equally.” This dual pursuit of truth and love is a resonant message for today’s polarized society.
However, while I found the theological insights invaluable, I did wish Ortlund would delve deeper into the role of politics in dividing the church. In a polarized climate, a system like his could serve as a useful tool for navigating ideological divides. Yet, I understand that this is primarily a theological discussion, and perhaps it’s a topic for another day.
Ultimately, I wholeheartedly recommend Finding the Right Hills to Die On to any Christian grappling with where to draw the line in matters of faith. This book is not just for theologians or church leaders; it’s for anyone seeking a thoughtful exploration of unity and division in Christianity. Ortlund’s gentle yet profound guidance invites us to reflect on our personal convictions and encourages us to check our hearts, fostering a spirit of love and unity that honors Christ.
In a world so often marked by division, this book inspired me to cherish the essential truths of my faith while advocating for unity even with those with whom I may disagree. There’s wisdom in Ortlund’s pages that feels imperative for this season, reminding us to choose our battles with care and love. 🌟
Discover more about Finding the Right Hills to Die on: The Case for Theolog… on GoodReads >>